MarketPeel
Insider Trading Intelligence
TM

Thomas A. Mccarthy

SIGI
DIRECTOR · SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC · CIK 0001500886
FILING MIX · LIFETIME90%/10%
BUYS
18
SELLS
2
TOTAL VALUE
$557.2K
COMPANIES
2
ACTIVE SINCE
May 2020
HOLDINGS NOW
33,642
AVG SELL PX
TRADE KIND
SHOWING 20 / 20
Trades · vs SPY
Loading price series…
Performance · forward returns vs SPY
2 backtested trades · 8 horizons · 2 pendingHow are these numbers computed? →
Forward-return performance of every backtestable P/S trade by Thomas A. Mccarthy, measured at 8 horizons from 7 days to 2 years. Deduped per economic event so co-filings count once. Excess return = trade return minus SPY return over the same window.
HORIZONTRADESWIN RATEINSIDER RETURNSPY RETURNMEAN EXCESSMEDIAN EXCESST-STAT
7d2+100.00%+3.99%-0.77%+4.76%+4.76%
14d2+50.00%+3.75%+0.75%+3.01%+3.01%
30d2+100.00%+3.09%+2.69%+0.40%+0.40%
60d2+100.00%+11.76%+4.85%+6.91%+6.91%
90d2+50.00%+9.31%+7.26%+2.05%+2.05%
180d2+100.00%+16.56%+10.57%+5.99%+5.99%
1y2(1 pending)+100.00%+41.90%+11.51%+30.39%+30.39%
2y2(1 pending)+100.00%+40.53%+42.93%-2.40%-2.40%
How to read this: Insider Returnis the average raw return of the filer's trades over the horizon. SPY Return is what SPY did over those same windows — reference only, not a comparison. The headline alpha number is Mean Excess = Insider − SPY; green means the filer beat SPY, red means they trailed it. Win rate is the share of individual trades where the filer beat SPY. T-statvalues above 2 mean the alpha is unlikely to be chance given the sample size. "Pending" counts trades where the horizon hasn't elapsed yet; their stats are not included in the row average.
Holdings over time
SIGI · 5,658.849 shares · as of May 1, 2026
04,6879,37314,06018,746202120222023202420252026SHARES HELD
Trading cadence · quarterly flow
BUY SELL
2020
2020
2020
2021
2021
2021
2021
2022
2022
2022
2022
2023
2023
2023
2023
2024
2024
2024
2024
2025
2025
2025
2025
2026
2026
FLOW · 18 buys / 2 sellsCOVERAGE · 25 quarters
Form 4 filings · all activity
COMPANYTYPESHARESPRICEVALUEHELD AFTERTRADE DATEFILEDDETAILS
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
8,46327,983May 20, 2026May 22, 2026View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
3,0475,658.849May 1, 2026May 4, 2026View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASE
2,500$77.42$193.6K18,746Jul 28, 2025Jul 29, 2025View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
8,39619,520May 21, 2025May 23, 2025View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
1,4262,583.37May 2, 2025May 5, 2025View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
SALEGRANT
Gift
16,2461,143.347Aug 21, 2024Aug 21, 2024View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Gift
16,24616,246Aug 21, 2024Aug 21, 2024View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Gift
41,48741,487Aug 21, 2024Aug 23, 2024View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
SALEGRANT
Gift
41,48711,124Aug 21, 2024Aug 23, 2024View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASE
10,000$16.37$163.7K52,611May 23, 2024May 23, 2024View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
11,12442,611May 22, 2024May 23, 2024View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
2,17917,385.184May 3, 2024May 6, 2024View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
7,75831,487Jul 1, 2023Jul 5, 2023View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
2,03315,192.387May 5, 2023May 8, 2023View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
7,42523,729May 27, 2022Jun 1, 2022View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
2,28213,143.781May 6, 2022May 9, 2022View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
8,695$23.00$200.0K16,304May 3, 2021May 4, 2021View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
2,16810,847.716Apr 30, 2021May 3, 2021View →
PRVA
PRIVIA HEALTH GROUP, INC.
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
7,6097,609Apr 28, 2021Apr 30, 2021View →
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
PURCHASEGRANT
Stock grant
3,5758,656.901May 7, 2020May 8, 2020View →
Other insiders · SIGI
Loading peer insiders…
About this filer
CIK 0001500886
ROLE
Director
PRIMARY
SIGI
COMPANIES
2
ACTIVE SINCE
May 2020
MARKETPEEL · /INSIDER/0001500886DATA · SEC EDGAR · FORM 4 · CONSOLIDATED TAPE
FREE · DAILY · 6 AM ET

One short email. Insider buys, congressional trades, and plain-English analysis.

Feedback